Most refreshing about Miss Underwood is her utter lack of artifice. When you look into the warm hazel eyes of this sweet-natured girl next door, you find no pretense, cynicism or delusions. "My happiness comes from being at home, whether it's with my mom and dad or, I hope, with a romantic interest later in life," she says.

A sensitive manly man who loves the outdoors is the fella apt to win her heart. "I like the genuineness of shy guys," Sara says. "Girls can shave their legs and spend time thinking about what looks good, but I want a guy to just grab the first clothes he sees in the morning and be natural."